news

Understanding Retirement Plan Fees

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

A well-run 401(k) plan is a powerful tool for attracting and retaining talent and providing employees with a path to retirement. While several details contribute to a plan’s success, fees are among the most critical. Some appear as small percentages across multiple providers rather than a clear line item, which makes them easy to overlook.

But plan fees can impact the bottom line and reduce what your employees have when they retire. As a plan sponsor, it’s your legal responsibility to make sure costs are reasonable. The good news is that fees are one aspect of the retirement plan that you can control. This guide covers what you’re likely paying for, how to find these costs, and which questions to ask.  

Why Fees Deserve Your Attention

Small percentages add up. The U.S. Department of Labor illustrates this with a simple example. An employee with $25,000 in a 401(k) and 35 years until retirement would have about $227,000 at retirement if fees and expenses were 0.5% a year. At 1.5% a year, that balance would grow to only about $163,000. That one-percentage-point difference reduces the employee’s account by 28%.

It’s part of your job as a fiduciary.

Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), you must act in the participants’ best interests. This means ensuring that the service provider fees are reasonable for the service and quality provided, and that you continue to monitor those providers.

Your goal isn’t to find the least expensive plan, but to understand what you’re paying for, what you receive in return, and if the cost is worth it

Types of Plan Fees and How They Are Paid

The Department of Labor groups 401(k) fees into four broad categories:

Fee typeWhat it coversHow it’s usually charged
Plan administrationRecordkeeping, accounting, legal, custodial, and trustee services, plus extras like participant websites, call centers, and education.Paid by the employer or deducted from plan assets (employee’s invested assets). Some administrative fees can also be covered indirectly through paying higher investment fees.
InvestmentManaging the funds on your plan’s menu.A percentage of assets, built into each fund’s expense ratio.
AdvisorInvestment advisory services provided to the plan and education.Paid by the employer, or deducted from plan assets.
Individual serviceOptional features a participant chooses to use, such as taking a plan loan, distribution, or QDRO.Charged only to the participants who use the feature.

Investment fees are the easiest to overlook because they’re deducted from fund returns rather than shown as a separate charge on participant statements.

Who Pays and Where Fees Hide

Some employers pay administrative costs directly. Others pass them to the plan, where they’re either spread across accounts as a percentage of each participant’s balance or charged as a flat dollar amount per participant. Neither approach is wrong, but each affects employees differently. A percentage-based fee falls more heavily on employees with larger balances, while a flat fee weighs more on employees with smaller ones.

The harder part is spotting costs that aren’t labeled as fees at all. A few to look for:

  • Revenue sharing: Some funds pay part of their expense ratio to the recordkeeper or other providers to cover plan administration. This can make a plan look “free” to the employer while participants pay through higher fund costs. (As with most things that look free, someone is paying. It’s usually worth finding out who.)
  • Share classes: The same fund is often available in several share classes with different expense ratios. A plan may be using a more expensive class than it needs to.
  • Sales charges and 12b-1 fees: Some funds include commissions or ongoing marketing and distribution fees inside their costs.
  • Advisor compensation: It’s worth knowing exactly how your plan’s advisor is paid, and whether any of that compensation comes from the investments on your menu.

How to Find Your Plan’s Fees

You likely already have most of the information you need. It’s just spread across a few documents:

  • Service provider fee disclosures (often called 408(b)(2) disclosures): Recordkeepers, advisors, and other covered providers are required to tell you, as the responsible plan fiduciary, what services they provide and what they’re paid, both directly and indirectly. This document must be provided to the plan fiduciary (e.g. the plan sponsor/employer or trustee). If you can’t find yours, ask your providers for a current copy.
  • Participant fee disclosures (often called 404(a)(5) notices): These annual notices show employees the fees and expenses tied to the plan and each investment option. Reading yours shows you exactly what your employees see.
  • Form 5500: Your plan’s annual filing with the federal government includes information on plan expenses and, for larger plans, service provider compensation.
  • Fund fact sheets and prospectuses: These list each fund’s expense ratio and share class.

If these documents are hard to piece together, that’s worth noting too. Clear, complete answers from your providers are a good sign. Vague ones are worth a follow-up. If a provider can’t explain its fees, this is, in its own way, an answer.

Value Matters More Than Price

A plan that costs a bit more but provides strong participant education or better investment options may be the right choice. What matters is that you can explain why the fees make sense for the services your plan receives, and that you’ve documented how you reached that conclusion.

A practical way to do that is to benchmark your plan’s fees against similar plans every few years and review your providers on a regular schedule. Along the way, these questions can help:

  1. What is the total cost of our plan, including investment fees, as a percentage of plan assets?
  2. Who pays each fee: the employer or individual participants?
  3. Does any provider receive revenue sharing, commissions, or other indirect compensation?
  4. Are we using the lowest-cost share class available for each fund?
  5. Has our plan grown enough since we last reviewed fees to qualify for better pricing?
  6. Is our advisor acting as a fiduciary to the plan, and in what capacity?
  7. When did we last benchmark our fees, and is that review documented?

How We Think about Plan Fees

At Armbruster Capital Management, we start from a simple belief: your employees take the investment risk, so they should keep as much of the return as possible. As an independent, SEC-registered investment adviser, we serve as a fiduciary, and we don’t earn commissions on the investments we recommend. When we review a plan, we look at every layer of cost and explain what each one pays for so plan sponsors can show how they reached their decisions.

Take the Next Step

If you’d like to see where your plan stands, start with our free 401(k) Plan Sponsor Checklist. It takes about 10 minutes and covers fees, fiduciary responsibilities, SECURE 2.0 updates, and employee engagement.

Or, if you’d rather talk it through, we offer a free plan review. It’s a 15-minute call with no cost or obligation. To schedule one, contact Maggie Broomfield, Financial Advisor, at (585) 381-4180 or mbroomfield@armbrustercapital.com.


Disclaimer: Views are subject to change based on market conditions and other factors. These views should not be construed as a recommendation for any specific security or sector. Investing involves risks, and the value of your investment will fluctuate over time. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

This article is for educational purposes and is not legal or tax advice; plan sponsors should consult their ERISA counsel or other qualified professionals about their specific plan.

Share this Article

Share
LinkedIn
Email
Print